HooliganOnE
: Manchestaaaaahhhhh! You mad fer iiiiitttt?
Who dare's to doubt that they are the best band in the world?POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 05:39 am / quote |
kaptink
: I wouldn't say the best band in the world. But classic Oasis is damn close!POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 06:48 am / quote |
shifty33
: Dunno about 'best in world' but i'd like to think they are. Their music is what got me into guitar in the first place. I love Oasis but think the Beatles were the original 'Best in the world' in their era !POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 07:51 am / quote |
jaxtheaxe
: personally thought the DVD was a little pointless. Still worth a watch 6/10POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 08:06 am / quote |
tidspanik
: Were can you see the SNL joke? Can't find it on youtube or at SNL's homepage. However, there is a nice clip on youtube with a great performance by Oasis (and a HILARIOUS ending) on SNL in '97.POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 09:57 am / quote |
Jalopy1919
: tidspanik wrote:
Were can you see the SNL joke? Can't find it on youtube or at SNL's homepage. However, there is a nice clip on youtube with a great performance by Oasis (and a HILARIOUS ending) on SNL in '97. |
you mean the one with Noel scratching himself?POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 11:11 am / quote |
LiamGallagher
: 20,000? at the Manchester gig? Bollocks, it was 60,000+POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 01:01 pm / quote |
Serjem
: i love oasis :PPOSTED: 11/15/2007 - 01:49 pm / quote |
Social D Rox
: One of my faves. That new single isnt too great though. Im excited for the new album though. Mid December baby. POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 01:51 pm / quote |
emi_becker
: oasis is the worst and more mediocre band i ever heardPOSTED: 11/15/2007 - 03:14 pm / quote |
Jalopy1919
: emi_becker wrote:
oasis is the worst and more mediocre band i ever heard |
Have you actually heard an Oasis CD?POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 03:48 pm / quote |
digweed6969
: Social D Rox wrote:
One of my faves. That new single isnt too great though. Im excited for the new album though. Mid December baby. |
The new oasis album is not coming out till way later next year, at best. It wouldn't shock me if we didn't hear it till 2009! December haha .. POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 04:28 pm / quote |
notsojoeyb4eva
: oasis is the worst and more mediocre band i ever heard
|
Your so far from wrong that 'right' is now but a pimple on your feeble mind.
Oasis are will and will be forever the greatest band on earth since the beatles.POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 04:45 pm / quote |
manu777
: oasis is the only true rock and roll band today man. everything else is emo, punk, alternative, indie, or some other subspecies.....come on...you don't see performances like Familiar To Millions anymore.
you may like it or not, but you can't call them mediocre. So they're not famous in america, big deal...they are everywhere else...POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 05:30 pm / quote |
properBo
: manu777 wrote:
So they're not famous in america, big deal...they are everywhere else... |
That doesn't make them a good band. POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 05:58 pm / quote |
Abe
: ^Crap bands can't get massive all over the world, it just doesn't happen. The fact they are big all over the world makes them at the very least a 'good' band, because mediocre bands don't manage it either. So what you said is total crap IMO.
The only reason Oasis are massive all around the world is because millions and millions of people think they're great.
POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 06:57 pm / quote |
CurtisJay
: exactly, the beatles, were famous world wide, i dont understand peoples obsession with oasis, the have simple songs, with open chords, that dont appeal to me at allPOSTED: 11/15/2007 - 06:59 pm / quote |
SkinnyWhiteBoy
: I'll admit, Wonderwall was a great tune, but for Christ's sake they don't deserve the "Best band in the world" title! Yes, they're a nice listen, I'm sure of it, but mass appeal doesn't make a band any better than another. I also find the argument of popularity to be stupid. It's like saying Fall Out Boy is simply amazing because they are widely successful. Yes, they might be the most fantastic to someone, as they probably are to many, but that doesn't make them better than anyone else. They just know how to be attractive to people (not just talking about their looks). Or, perhaps, saying that Bush was a great president in '04 because he won the election.
Yeah, sorry, Oasis might be terrific and groundbreaking for some, but I'll take my Mars Volta over them any day of the week. 
(please, refrain from turning this into an argument, I was simply just stating my opinion)POSTED: 11/15/2007 - 07:49 pm / quote |
manu777
: I admit that world wide success doesn't make a band good. After all there are crap bands that are famous too.
But i'm willing to learn. Anyone who doesnt like Oasis, just name bands you like, or a band that you think is the best band in the world, but that are in the same genre as Oasis, which is main stream, larger than life, straight up rock & roll. After all you can't compare Oasis to Gym Class Heroes (i can't stand them by the way), anymore than you can compare Techno to Hip Hop
And there's nothing wrong with a song being simple. I don't get this obsession people have with complexity.
"wish you were here", "knocking on heaven's door", "mr. tambourine man" "imagine", "american pie", anything by the beatles, (and more of course) are some the easiest to play, and some of the greatest songs of all time.
POSTED: 11/16/2007 - 12:35 am / quote |
Roland_Casey
: FANS LIKE ME SHOULD BUY THIS. BUT HAVE TO SAY DISC 1 IS BORING. DISC 2 CAN BLOW YOUR MIND. AND THE PICTURES IS CLEAR.(HD? I AM NOT SURE)POSTED: 11/21/2007 - 03:11 am / quote |
Wannabe Page!
: Roland_Casey wrote:
FANS LIKE ME SHOULD BUY THIS. BUT HAVE TO SAY DISC 1 IS BORING. DISC 2 CAN BLOW YOUR MIND. AND THE PICTURES IS CLEAR.(HD? I AM NOT SURE) |
disk 1 isn't boring you ****ing knobhead...if u are a fan u'll love it. it's just a different approach
but disk 2 is absolutely stunning.
A MUST HAVE!POSTED: 11/26/2007 - 07:19 am / quote |
Micky!
: thats rock n roll for u!!!POSTED: 12/21/2007 - 04:53 pm / quote |
Micky!
: Fock off roland casey ya queer
POSTED: 12/21/2007 - 04:54 pm / quote |
timoi1
: I am a massive Oasis fan, but I do feel slightly cheated Almost this entire documentary was on Channel 4 quite a while ago. I can't be certain but it was about 6-9 months back and a lot of the stuff on the documentary I'd already seen before. I'm surprised no one else has realised. Obviously there's quite a chunk of new stuff and I got it for christmas so I'm not complaining. The audio commentary is very funny too, with some great running gags. Disc 2 is great as wellPOSTED: 12/28/2007 - 03:23 pm / quote |
jv_music
: They can be the best band or close to it in the world statistically, but there's always haters and lovers. It's like Led Zeppelin. Almost every guitarist probably loves them or at least respect them, but there's always a hater.manu777 wrote:
I admit that world wide success doesn't make a band good. After all there are crap bands that are famous too.
But i'm willing to learn. Anyone who doesnt like Oasis, just name bands you like, or a band that you think is the best band in the world, but that are in the same genre as Oasis, which is main stream, larger than life, straight up rock & roll. After all you can't compare Oasis to Gym Class Heroes (i can't stand them by the way), anymore than you can compare Techno to Hip Hop
And there's nothing wrong with a song being simple. I don't get this obsession people have with complexity.
"wish you were here", "knocking on heaven's door", "mr. tambourine man" "imagine", "american pie", anything by the beatles, (and more of course) are some the easiest to play, and some of the greatest songs of all time.
|
+1
And well, every band/genre will have a fan base. You can write songs about eating s*** and I bet there's gonna be a fan base. People's taste are different anyways. POSTED: 07/14/2008 - 11:54 pm / quote |
|