Yespleasevicar
: I disagreee with Malmsteen being the best there,he has (especially on this dvd) a real big Shut up problem. Theres times where vai is talking to the crowd and he stops cos malmsteens doing the same thing sweepy thingy.By far the least versatile musician of the bunch.
Saying that the jam was great, and Little wing was awesome.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 04:49 am / quote |
blade'sedge
: i got this dvd a while back, absolutly awsome, im not sure what this guys on about, the production quality is fine, and for malmsteen being the best of the three, boloks, he really isn't my vote is definately satriani, he's just too cool for his own good. also i loved one of the songs when get a bit of a nice bass solo, it's not quite cliff burton but i loved it. overall awsome reallyPOSTED: 05/24/2006 - 05:40 am / quote |
koirala
: its a fuuckin gud dvd but special features suck .yingwie sang terrible in voodoo chile they should have made that one better starry night was gud ya n the best was keep in rockin in the free world this is a song baby a ****in gud onePOSTED: 05/24/2006 - 05:47 am / quote |
leander m.
: Why not michael angelo batio to the next G3 concert?? Vai and Satch will be overwhelmed by angelo and they will look like little kids on the stage hehehehe..nice song on little wingPOSTED: 05/24/2006 - 06:54 am / quote |
thepagesaretorn
: this is the one w/ the triple necked jem right?
anyways...(to leander m.) no. Michael Angelo Batio is not better than Vai.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 07:14 am / quote |
dimebag7
: yeah i liked malmsteen the best there, then joe. steve vai is good, but he didnt do it for me this time.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 07:16 am / quote |
metalicon
: yeah, it seemed like while vai and satriani were playing along with the song, Malmsteen would constanly do sweep arpeggios just to show off how awesome he is which in my opinion, moderation is the true meaning of genius. As for Michael Angelo Batio, good guitarist but he looks like Nigel Tufnel off of Spinal Tap.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 09:53 am / quote |
crzywhiteboy
: you should have got the G3 with Eric Johnson,its the best one so far...POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 09:57 am / quote |
Night Revolver
: Eric Johnson in the G3 was awesome ... He's really in a class of his own. Certainly was the best guy so far in GS. Malmsteen was alright. Petrucci was mediocre.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 11:08 am / quote |
DaBlackE
: I havent heard this CD but saw this concert on its opening date in Phoenix. These guys are the 3 best guitarist around. Maybe not the best singers, but the best guitarists.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 11:28 am / quote |
E-MAN0221
: i love this dvd!!! its my fav G3!!! i like steve and yngwie but i cant stop listening to satriani... by all means my favorite guitarist ever!!! ever since i 1st saw him on this dvd! and by the way Angelo is good, but all his stuff is SO GAY, all you really hear is noise... he is exagratinly to fast... satriani is my fav!POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 01:27 pm / quote |
SkinnyWhiteBoy
: leander m. wrote:
Why not michael angelo batio to the next G3 concert?? Vai and Satch will be overwhelmed by angelo and they will look like little kids on the stage hehehehe..nice song on little wing |
Micheal Angelo is fast... that's it... and I'd argue that Herman Li of Dragonforce is a better (maybe even faster) shredder than Angelo. Satriani and Vai have the technicality, but also the ability to make it sound great. POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 04:40 pm / quote |
ToesKa
: like vai and satch on this one... malmsteen annoyes me like hell on this dvd... I loved the part in rocking in the free world where they all do a solo, and fist satch sets of a kick ass solo, then malmsteen does his ladders, and with one crying note vai just erases everything malmsteen did before... lovely just lovelyPOSTED: 05/24/2006 - 05:16 pm / quote |
KissingShadows
: SkinnyWhiteBoy wrote:
leander m. wrote:
Why not michael angelo batio to the next G3 concert?? Vai and Satch will be overwhelmed by angelo and they will look like little kids on the stage hehehehe..nice song on little wing
Micheal Angelo is fast... that's it... and I'd argue that Herman Li of Dragonforce is a better (maybe even faster) shredder than Angelo. Satriani and Vai have the technicality, but also the ability to make it sound great. |
Herman Li isnt at all in a class anywhere near Angelo, who isnt anywhere near Vai/Satch. Angelo is good, Li is ok, but niether have the minds to produce music or the ability to shred as well as Vai/Satch. Maybe someday though...although I highly doubt anyone in the next ten years will be able to match up to Vai/Satch to make a really good G3. I saw Eric Johnson, Vai, and Satch at Satch's LA Concert for Super Col. earlier this month and that wasy insanely badass, but even Johnson doesnt posess the skill required to match them.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 06:38 pm / quote |
Ibzman
: Uh rectification for all of you guys here, Satch and Vai ARENT SHREDDERS AT ALL, they play awesome music without the necessity of always do the fastest they can, look at Joe Satriani's "Super Colossal", one of his better cd for sure, and Vai doesn't shred either.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 07:51 pm / quote |
dan_the_pie
: satch and vai arent shredders? are you an idiot?POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 08:11 pm / quote |
Giao
: are you?POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 08:22 pm / quote |
Weybl Himself
: leander m. wrote:
Why not michael angelo batio to the next G3 concert?? Vai and Satch will be overwhelmed by angelo and they will look like little kids on the stage hehehehe..nice song on little wing |
Michael Angelo Baito is just a wank, no real melodic structure or feeling, Vai and Satch kick his ass in songwriting and arrangements all day long.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 09:34 pm / quote |
Gman400
: Batio would suck. Amazing skill but his songs are just horrible other than a couple riffs.
I also liked Malmsteen the most, seconded by Vai and way in last comes Satriani IMO. I hate that guy for somre reason.POSTED: 05/24/2006 - 10:57 pm / quote |
wootlooops
: I know you're all knockin on Yngwie here, but that second song he busts into on this CD kicks ass! That first 30-45 seconds of riffing before he busts into his obnoxious, mundane shredding is amazing. Does anyone know the title of that song? The second song Yngwie played is the only clue I can give.POSTED: 05/25/2006 - 02:19 am / quote |
that1l)ude
: | Michael Angelo Baito is just a wank, no real melodic structure or feeling, Vai and Satch kick his ass in songwriting and arrangements all day long. |
None of the guitarists(Except Petrucci)Mentioned in this thread can write a song thatll keep my attention for over 2 seconds. great guitarits but too showy for their own goodPOSTED: 05/25/2006 - 05:37 am / quote |
sinan90
: i think that the vai and malmsteen solos are a bit OTT on little wing, you need somethign simpler to fit the songPOSTED: 07/07/2006 - 06:18 am / quote |
Shreddin 4 Life
: Man, you guys all gotta just shut up and enjoy this DVD for what it is. The musicians are amazing-end of story. Besides, MAB would suck in G3-he'd just be shredding & shredding & shredding non-stop until everyone pukes.
Furthermore, if you're not a shred or general soloing fan, get lost because that's what G3 is all about.
Also, the production quality obviously won't touch the Tokyo one because the Tokyo G3 came AFTER Denver.
And finally, you ALL have to stop being so critical of any of the guitarists mentioned in this commenting section, whether you like them or not, at least 3/4 of any of you will never even be able to scratch the surface of their playing skill and composing abilities, so like I said earlier, just sit back and enjoy some of the greatest guitarists of all time!!!POSTED: 07/07/2006 - 11:36 am / quote |
Ischi
: Anyone who says malmsteen is better than Vai or Satch should be shot, twice, in the foot. Sure, he can play fast, but who wants to listen to neo classical shred, and the same sweep patterns over and over and over and over and over and over and over again 
POSTED: 07/24/2006 - 09:53 am / quote |
Shreddin 4 Life
: Ischi :
Anyone who says malmsteen is better than Vai or Satch should be shot, twice, in the foot. Sure, he can play fast, but who wants to listen to neo classical shred, and the same sweep patterns over and over and over and over and over and over and over again |
What's wrong w/ neo-classical shred?
U obviously don't know Yngwie outside this DVD cuz he's a lot more versatile than u pass him off to be...POSTED: 07/27/2006 - 02:24 pm / quote |
Bill.x
: Eric Johnson Is By far the best guitarist to play with G3.
Althought Satch and Vai are in a complete class of their own.
Nobody On the world stage has ever been as technically brilliant as Satch and Vai. POSTED: 08/22/2006 - 06:38 am / quote |
DTFatesWarningX
: Yngwie bores me. He's too much about speed and not enough about substance. Satch and Vai can play though. Haha, I'm not surprised no one brought up the G3 with Fripp.POSTED: 08/26/2006 - 01:53 pm / quote |
fluffylump2
: this dvd is awesome. it has steve vai doing "Get the Hell Outta Here" which is an amazing song where his whole bands plays each other's instruments. yeah, it's really good.POSTED: 08/26/2006 - 08:58 pm / quote |
mbuu007
: NO the person who should be in g3 next should be paul gilber of marty friedman!POSTED: 08/27/2006 - 09:33 pm / quote |
slv
: Malmsteen played like an ass on this dvd. was completely let down compared to what i had heard about him. steve vai was the best by a mile and he reallly killed it. the best GV3 dvd to buy, G3 Live in Tokyo.POSTED: 10/03/2006 - 07:07 am / quote |
detranova
: mbuu007 wrote:
NO the person who should be in g3 next should be paul gilber of marty friedman! |
I think Friedman actually hopped on stage for G3 in Tokyo, but they weren't able to put that footage on the DVD (or they might just have not recorded it).POSTED: 10/16/2006 - 06:33 pm / quote |
Linus Satriani
: Yeah, I agree with the majority. I dont like yngwie, he is good, very very good but not my style at all. I believe that Vai is the best guitarist in the world technically. But Satch do the best songs. He's amazing. I love everything he does.
My fav G3 is with Eric Johnson, going down just blew me away, same thing with Red House. And Johnsons "manhattan" is just amazing. POSTED: 01/04/2007 - 06:31 pm / quote |
Build An Army
: Yeah i agree totally with 'Linus Satriani', i dont like yngwie that much, he puts no really feeling into the songs he does, he plays fast thats it... Now if Jason Becker was still playing then we would have one hell of a G3 concert with him, Satch and Vai.
I cant wait for this years G3 though, its with Gilbert, he is one of the greats in my opinion, so inventive of what he does and what he can do with the guitar is just immense!
And i think that the one with Eric Johnson in doing Red House was 1992 (i think)POSTED: 03/20/2007 - 05:49 am / quote |
Build An Army
: Build An Army wrote:
Yeah i agree totally with 'Linus Satriani', i dont like yngwie that much, he puts no really feeling into the songs he does, he plays fast thats it... Now if Jason Becker was still playing then we would have one hell of a G3 concert with him, Satch and Vai.
I cant wait for this years G3 though, its with Gilbert, he is one of the greats in my opinion, so inventive of what he does and what he can do with the guitar is just immense!
And i think that the one with Eric Johnson in doing Red House was 1992 (i think) |
My mistake, it was 1997 he played with themPOSTED: 03/20/2007 - 09:16 am / quote |
udy
: First I very like all G3. Mainly Vai and Satch have given me the best. I fan for Yngwie but He is to much playing in a supergroup. He is very strong and there are some scenes where his friends are back. In my opinion Gilbert would be a decent choice. POSTED: 05/10/2007 - 05:56 pm / quote |
I'm a real boy
: this is another fine example of overreacting. the first dude said that if it were stolen, he'd hunt down whoever stole it and smash him over the head with a cheap guitar, if the said situation should arise, just buy another one people.
POSTED: 07/10/2007 - 09:16 am / quote |
jcgmed
: I don't think that players like Batio, Malmsteen and similars would be able to play on G3, the super - virtuoso rol is ok if you are taking technique lessons and similars, but playing on stage is a musical thing.
The chromatical crazy runs played by Petrucci were a lot more interesting than the almost-vomitive Malmsteen's sweep picking impros in Rocking In The Free World, and his intro in the central main solo...the same boring whole tone modulation, before a too dirty arpeggio runs and, and, at the end...his golden rolex crashing with the 1st string...
Oh yes, Hendryx's Voddo Child was...Vodoo music ( just listen the outro in the main solo...Malmsteen was a thousand light-years away, planning his next dirty speedy vomit ).
Maybe if Batio joins G3, the whole jam could be some Nintendo's music, like Mario Bros o Zelda's soundtracks.POSTED: 11/25/2007 - 01:50 pm / quote |
Otnip
: I have to admit something here...
Malmsteen's solos were so repetitive and out of place in the G3 Jams I muted my TV every time it was his turn.
That guy has the hugest ego, and it annoys the crap out of me the crowd got the most out of his neo classical shred only set list...
Satch and Vai were great. POSTED: 01/31/2008 - 07:15 pm / quote |
|